spikesgirl58 (spikesgirl58) wrote in mfu_canteen,
spikesgirl58
spikesgirl58
mfu_canteen

One from the Vaults - Pinky Ring and the Brain

Back in 2009, bluemeanybeanyposted:

Me and Cosmosmariner were discussing this earlier, so I thought I'd open up the discussion...

How smart is Illya? Is he a child prodigy? OK so he has a PhD and is Dr Kuryakin but that doesnt mean all that much. In terms of actual assignments he's nowhere near as science/nerdy/academic as say Spock, or Carter and Daniel Jackson from Stargate.

Generally I think in fanfic he's written as much smarter than he is in the show. Is there any evidence in the episodes of him possessing an eidetic memory for example [i cant remember because I dont have one : ]
Quite a lot of Illya fans say they fell in love with him beause he was the smart one. [well that's *cough* one of the reasons anyway]

And conversely, are we unnecessarily harsh on poor old blockhead Napoleon? Illya is at times particularly scathing of Solo's mental powers, but that would appear to be unjustified. I think Napoleon could do all the science and maths if he so chose [he may be slightly lazy about that sort of stuff though] To quote Captain Mal, "Yes, I have read a poem."

So, what say you, cousins? Do you think Illya is the brains or does Napoleon have a brain in that pretty little head of his? to visit the original discussion, check it out here.
Tags: question of the day
Subscribe

  • Just wondering

    What is it about Man from UNCLE that has kept you as a fan? Was it the writing, the genre, the actors, or something entirely else? I loved the…

  • Today's Blue Plate Specials

    Today in the Canteen we have honey-mustard chicken and pasta salad with dragon fruit cheesecake for dessert

  • To tell the truth

    And you can trust us to not spread your little secrets... okay, who's laughing... What do you hate the most about getting older? And seeing how I…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 24 comments

  • Just wondering

    What is it about Man from UNCLE that has kept you as a fan? Was it the writing, the genre, the actors, or something entirely else? I loved the…

  • Today's Blue Plate Specials

    Today in the Canteen we have honey-mustard chicken and pasta salad with dragon fruit cheesecake for dessert

  • To tell the truth

    And you can trust us to not spread your little secrets... okay, who's laughing... What do you hate the most about getting older? And seeing how I…